Catholic YM Blog

Scott BlogThe Catholic YM Blog has been referred to as "the 411 of Catholic Youth Ministry." Your blogger is D. Scott Miller, former director of the Division of Youth and Young Adult Ministry for the Archdiocese of Baltimore... Read more...

Recent Posts

Recent Comments


Catholic Ministry Ad

16Apr, 2012

Stepping Beyond Our Ground

UPDATE: I was interviewed on the Morning Air show with Sean Herriott this morning on this topic.  Find a recording after the jump.

The sad, sad story of Trayvon Martin and George Zimmerman continues to remain in our national consciousness.  It has primarily been presented as a primary evidence that we are still not getting race relations right. The subsequent marches, rallies, and speeches have all alluded to it.

Treyvon was a African-American 17 year old who was deemed suspicious wearing a hoodie and beign black within a gated community. President Obama waded into the turbulent waters of issue by stating  "If I had a son, he’d look like Trayvon."  which I should suggest encourages to look at this case not only through the lens of race but also with a focus on generations.

If Treyvon was a 15 or 20  years older walking from the convenience store on a Skittle run wearing a button down shirt and a tie…

Relevantradio041612 by CatholicYMblog

I contend that race does become a cause of suspicion for 20-something Zimmerman.  It was likely race, age, and the hoodie that all spoke of gangster fashion that cause fear and concern.

In the end, that’s not what we will be the discussion. The upcoming legal arguments will likely revolve around interpretations of one’s right to Stand Your Ground. As early as 1895,  the U.S. Supreme Court in Beard v. U.S.  declared that an innocent person under attack was, "not obliged to retreat, but was entitled to stand his ground, and meet any attack upon him with a deadly weapon, in such a way and with such force as … [he] honestly believed, and had reasonable grounds to believe, was necessary to save his own life, or to protect himself from great bodily injury."

As a society, has our perspective on the next generation transformed from a sense of special protection for the “Baby of Board” generation to the fear-filled perception of them as an intrusive hoodie-wearing threat? Jobs are limited, must we stand our ground and keep them outside the gated community of opportunity. We like our church worship and community exactly the way it is, we have reasonable grounds to protect ourselves from generational change and to segregate that younger generation.

And, we are not even standing ground on generational change. Thirty years ago, ten percent of California’s general fund went to higher education and 5% went to prisons. Today, nearly 11%  goes to prisons while higher education has decrease to eight percent. The cost of enrollment in Princeton for a year is less than the cost of housing a prisoner in a New Jersey jail. <source> As a society, we need to do better by the next generation than just to stand our ground went confronted by them.

Here’s the challenge. “Stand Your Ground” is not an anticipated stance of a disciple of Christ. Our Lord reminds us to “offer no resistance to one who is evil” and to turn the other cheek. Our primary stance to an other is not as an enemy by as a neighbor deserving of our love. Youth ministry leader Adam McLane looks through his own office window daily and sees within his neighborhood many of God’s children looking remarkably like Trayvon. He wonders about the many Trayvon Martins walking by on his way to the store, the Trayvon’s riding by on bikes, those of a different race and the Trayvon’s who are girls. He suggests that the teenagers in his neighborhood are probably a lot like the teenagers in your neighborhood, who are also just like the teenagers in Trayvon Martin’s neighborhood.

“Stand Your Ground” is not an anticipated stance of a disciple of Christ. We are called to go (not stand… what part of go do we fail to comprehend?) and make disciples of all the nations.  And that all the nations stuff seems most likely to include all the generations. We are called towards stepping beyond protecting ourselves in our fear-induced ground and responding to our sons, our daughters, our nieces and nephews, and all those neighbor kids who look like Treyvon. <Image: Justin Nether, via Baltimore Sun>


No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.